Author Archives: admin

IVGID’s Management response to forensic audit report

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

Below is the evaluation of IVGID’s Mgmt response to the Rubin Brown Forensic Audit Report , written by an  Artificial Intelligence Bot. Our human observations are that there will be no change in IVGID or its culture of no controls, based on continued stonewalling regard financial records. For fiscal year 2023, the General Ledger is over $4 million out of balance (as of 8-3-2024) while the fiscal year 2024 is over $15 million out of balance (as of 7-10-2024). Clearly the Tyler Munis is not properly implemented. In a  Committee meeting on Local Government Finance at the State of Nevada … Continue reading →

IVGID Forensic Audit Report Released: What Property Owners Need to Know

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

“The scope of the audit was to identify fraud risk, it was not to identify fraud.”    IVGID Trustee Ray Tulloch, August 7, 2024, Committee meeting on Local Government Finance – State of Nevada Tax Department And that is why the report doesn’t include the word F-R-A-U-D. Because Trustee Tulloch and General Manager Bobby Magee made sure FRAUD was not in SCOPE. This was a BAIT-AND-SWITCH as the original audit scope in the RFP was clear. *** The long-awaited and carefully worded forensic audit report for the Incline Village General Improvement District (IVGID) has been released, revealing significant concerns about … Continue reading →

IVGID General Manager quits after three months

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

UPDATE: In an email to a resident, Human Resources Director Erin Feore confirmed both Bobby Magee, and Adam Cripps have left District employment. Both live in  the Southern California area. MS. Feore wrote, ” Bobby Magee has resigned his position from the Incline Village General Improvement  District, effective August 22, 2024. He is no longer working and he is no longer receiving a salary.   Adam Cripps has also resigned his position, Assistant Director of Finance,  with the District, effective August 26, 2024. He is no longer working; as such, he is no longer receiving a salary.”  Cripps had been … Continue reading →

Special Assessment – absent a benefit to the property assessed – is illegal and void

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

In City of Reno v. Folsom, the Nevada Supreme Court held that a special assessment tax was justifiable only if the proposed special assessment provided commensurate benefit: “It is well established that a special assessment, absent a benefit to the property assessed, is illegal and void.” What is the difference between the this case and the Incline Village General Improvement’s imposition of a “Recreation Facility Fee”? NOTHING. In 2021, 78% of IVGID punch cards issued WERE NOT REDEEMED. Over three THOUSAND parcel owners did not pick up any punch cards!  That is 44% (3,564 owners). Do these 3,564 owners all … Continue reading →

IVGID’s Auditor refuses to issue audit opinion

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

[Update Oct 11, 2024: The Nevada Department of Taxation issued a letter to IVGID saying they have not complied with NRS 354.624(4);  a disclaimer of opinion is NOT an opinion. The letter is below. The “damages” are the cost of doing the audit again – which is what will be required for IVGID to be in compliance.] CPA firm Davis Farr issued a “Disclaimer of Opinion”  letter to the Incline Village General Improvement District for the audit of its fiscal year ending June 30, 2023.  A disclaimer of opinion means there was not sufficient, appropriate evidence for auditors to even … Continue reading →

Appeal of signature verification for recall petition of IVGID Trustees denied

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

The Nevada Secretary of State’s office denied the appeal of the verification of signatures for petition to recall the Incline Village General Improvement District Trustees Sara Schmitz and Matthew Dent. In two letters dated March 1, 2024, NV SoS Deputy Secretary  Gabriel Di Chiara concluded, “In summary, the Secretary of State finds the petition remains insufficient. No further action will be taken on the appeal.” Letter re: Sara Schmitz Recall   

Continue reading →

Forensic Audit Authorized – but will it be a white-wash?

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

After years of residents’ complaining, the Board of the Incline Village General Improvement District (IVGID) authorized a forensic audit in November, 2023. This seemed a step in the right direction. Especially since, in October, 2023, we wrote how expenses had been hidden by IVGID for decades. This is financial statement fraud – like WorldCom in 2002.   link 1   link 2   link 3 We have also written about the financial systems meltdown after a failed accounting and payroll implementation and no fixed asset inventory for a decade or longer. link 1  link 2 Original Forensic Audit Scope In September, 2023 IVGID … Continue reading →

IVGID’s Financial Meltdown – Part 2

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

[UPDATE: Sunday, Nov 5, 2023 Several residents have emailed us expressing concerns and asking what they can do. We have some solution-oriented ideas and would like to share them with you. Email us at village_alliance at ourivcbvoice.com ] If you spent over half a million dollars for a computer system, wouldn’t you expect your staff to ensure the system worked before you turned off the old system?   This would be normal for a financial systems conversion. Some organizations elect to “run parallel” with their old system for several months to gain confidence and experience.   But not the Incline Village … Continue reading →

OPINION: Cooking the Books – Part 3

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

This article examines the Land in the Utilities account:  $6,715,543.64 according to the audited financial statements (6/30/2022). That $6,715,543.64 matches the Fixed Asset Ledger-Land-Utilities  exactly. That should be good – but it’s not. Why? Because the ledger does not contain accurate, supporting details. Only one item in the ledger contains  a parcel number. The FA Ledger for Land – Utilities ties exactly to the audited financials for 2022 back to 2009:  $6,715,544. And then from 2007,  the numbers don’t match  (graphic)– until magically they again match in 1990.   This is evidence the FA Ledger was created to tie to … Continue reading →

Recall fails to gather sufficient valid signatures

Our Incline Village Crystal Bay Voice Posted on by

The recall effort failed to gather sufficient signatures. The minimum requirement to qualify for a recall special ballot: 1801 valid and verified signatures of voters in the 2020 election. For IVGID Trustee Matthew Dent, there were 1,726 valid signatures submitted. For IVGID Trustee Sara Schmitz, there were 1,687 valid signatures submitted.. Both fell short. The process is now over unless there is a challenge with the Secretary of State.

Continue reading →